Skip to content
HomeAboutPricingSupportContact
All best practices
Contractors For maintenance engineers and managers

Diagnosis before cost: evaluating contractor quotes

The cheapest quote is often the one that misunderstood the fault. Telling the difference before you award the work takes a few minutes.

Comparing quotes on price is fast and frequently wrong. A number on its own carries no information about whether the contractor understood the problem. Ordering the evaluation (diagnosis, then approach, then parts, then price) costs a few minutes and changes outcomes.

Ask for four things, not a figure

  • The diagnosis: what the contractor believes is wrong, and what evidence supports it.
  • The proposed solution: what they intend to do about it.
  • The parts to be used: specification and origin, not just a line item.
  • The price, broken into labour and parts.

A contractor who will not provide the first three is telling you something useful about how they work.

Screen on diagnosis first

Read the diagnoses with the prices covered. Discard the ones that do not match what your own technician found, or that describe a symptom rather than a cause. Replacing a bearing that failed because of misalignment is a repair you will pay for twice.

Then compare like with like

Among the contractors who diagnosed correctly, differences in price are now meaningful, because they reflect the same job. This is also the point at which a higher quote can be argued for on the record, which matters when finance asks later.

Record the reasoning, not just the winner

One or two lines on why this contractor was selected turns an awarding decision into an auditable one, and gives your successor a reason rather than a mystery. It takes thirty seconds at the moment of decision and is unreconstructable six months later.

Watch for the pattern over time

Track which contractors’ diagnoses hold up. Rework against the same asset within ninety days is the cheapest quality signal available, and it will reorder your panel within two quarters.

Share LinkedIn X Email

Make good practice the default, not the effort

SaharaDesk turns these habits into workflow: thresholds that apply themselves, registers that stay honest, records that survive turnover.